What FAN means to
me
by Janet Nagel,
EdD
1) FAN is the go-to international
organization for information and networking in the world-wide campaign to end
the injustice and public health fiasco of fluoridation. FAN is a source of
support and inspiration for all of us who are committed to this
goal.
2) Fluoridation will end in the US
when most people realize that they’ve been deceived—snookered, I like to say.
And there are so many other good words for it. Let’s use them: conned, duped,
hoodwinked, hornswoggled, hustled, snowed, taken in, tricked . . . because
fluoridation is humbug, absurd, a scam, a hoax, a boondoggle, a cult . .
.
Using old Ed Bernays’ insidious
mind-molding techniques, most health professionals, politicians and ordinary
folks have been convinced—against logic and common sense--that just a “tiny bit”
of a powerful protoplasmic poison miraculously protects everyone from the pesky
scourge of tooth decay. Of course, like the courtiers of that well-known naked
emperor, one has to be of superior intelligence to understand that constant
exposure to a tiny bit of an accumulative poison is actually salutary. Human
rights zealots, freedom fanatics, legalistic sticklers, science deniers,
simpletons, rabble-rousers and others are, of course, not able to grasp this
arcane concept and need to be continually beaten back by the enlightened elite
;)
I think this deeply ingrained insider
snobbery is a compelling force keeping the fluoridation belief system in place.
And, as a former believer, I know it takes a while to break out of that
constantly reinforced brainwashing--like deprogramming someone rescued from a
cult.
To break through the “insiderism,” I’ve
come to think maybe ridicule can be a potent tool. We can spotlight our public
health “geniuses,” who can’t distinguish phony science from real science, who
don’t know the difference between concentration and dose, who can’t tell human
rights from a ham sandwich or professional ethics from a hockey puck. Yes,
fluoridation promoters are sinister, but they’re also silly, pompous,
overwrought ignoramuses. And laughter has more impact than
frowns.
3) In my child’s third year,
dentists in the Dental Faculty Practice at UNC Dental School in Chapel Hill, NC,
prescribed fluoride tablets and fluoride mouth rinse. The treatment needed to
be both topical and systemic, I was told. Being a well-schooled health
educator, I diligently followed the prescribed regimen. So, of course, when his
first permanent teeth emerged they were discolored by bright white flecks. They
were not attractive. The first few dentists I asked about this hemmed and
hawed. Finally one hesitantly told me it was dental fluorosis--from too much
fluoride. I was put out. No one ever told me that fluorosis was a possible
“side effect” of fluoride treatment. Not the grad school professors who sang
the praises of fluoridation, not the dentists who prescribed the treatments for
my child. We stopped all further use of fluoride, of course.
About that time we left NC to travel for
several years and gave up any thought of fluoride. In 1992 we had bought a
house in Bellingham, WA. I read in the paper that fluoridation of our water was
being proposed. I thought parents should be able to choose whether or not their
children are put at risk for dental fluorosis. My husband Harry and I went to
the city council meeting where it was going to be discussed. So did quite a few
other fluoridation objectors.
After the council meeting we all gathered
in the courthouse lobby. Anne Anderson and Richard Foulkes invited everyone to
meet at their home a few days later to discuss the situation. That was the
beginning of a 6-year collaboration, which stopped that fluoridation proposal in
Bellingham, defeated a pro-fluoridation city council candidate, and eventually
passed an ordinance prohibiting fluoridation in Bellingham. Anne and I made
several trips to the state capital to lobby against pro-fluoridation
legislation, and Anne and Richard became more widely involved in the efforts to
end this unethical, illogical and unhealthy practice.
I feel privileged to have been
mentored by Anne and Richard and also by John Lee who came to Bellingham to
assist us. Although Harry and I had to turn our focus to other things for a
number of years, fluoridation has remained a passion of mine. Back in North
Carolina, I now have some time to devote to it.
Janet Nagel, Ed.D., North Carolina.